Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner Review (2026): Worth It?
Prices and picks verified as of November 2026. Independent, reader-supported reviews.
Quick Answer
This Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner review compares its 100% cotton build, 70 by 72 inch size, and $60.68 price against a Martha Stewart cotton curtain and two narrower Bean Products organic cotton liners. Shoppers who want a plastic-free liner and don't mind adding a waterproof layer behind it get the most consistent match here, while anyone on a tighter budget should look at the lower-priced alternatives below first.
Our pick: Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub, $60.68 Check Price on Amazon
Bottom line: our top pick is the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner- at $50.11.
Things to Know Before You Buy
- The Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner is built from 100% cotton with no vinyl or PEVA, so it will not seal out water the way a typical plastic liner does.
- At $60.68, it costs more than the Martha Stewart cotton curtain and both of Bean Products' own organic cotton liners compared here, all of which fall between $43.52 and $59.99.
- It ships in a single 70 inch by 72 inch size, a standard fit for most tubs but not a match for narrower or extra-wide shower openings.
- The listing does not publish a star rating or review count, so there is no third-party track record to lean on beyond the material and price comparison in this review.
This Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner review puts the liner's 100% cotton build, $60.68 price, and 70 by 72 inch size next to three cotton alternatives shoppers often weigh against it: a printed Martha Stewart curtain and two of Bean Products' own organic cotton liners. Cotton liners like this one trade the sealed, waterproof surface of vinyl or PEVA for a breathable fabric that many shoppers choose specifically to avoid plastic in the bathroom. That tradeoff affects almost every decision that follows, including whether you need a separate liner behind it and how it compares on price against liners that handle water differently.
We built this comparison from the product listings, current Amazon pricing, and the material and size specifications each brand publishes for its own liner or curtain. None of the four options here lists a star rating or review count, so price, size, and construction carry more weight in this comparison than they would for a product with an established review history. The Bean Products liner sits at the top of the price range in this group at $60.68, roughly $17 more than its own stall-width organic cotton liners and about a dollar more than the Martha Stewart curtain. A reader deciding purely on price can stop there; a reader who cares about plastic-free construction, size, or pattern needs the detail in the sections below.
Why You Should Trust Us
Ilane Tall has covered bathroom fixtures and shower hardware for Best Shower Curtains since the site launched, and this Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner review follows the same research process used across the site: comparing manufacturer listings, current pricing, and published specifications rather than running a physical testing lab. We do not own a lab, and we do not claim hands-on use of any liner or curtain we cover, including this one. Instead, we pull the dimensions, materials, and prices straight from each retailer listing, then compare them against the other cotton options a shopper is likely to consider at checkout. The full methodology behind every review on this site lives on our how we research page, and we followed that same approach here, from the price comparison through the final verdict.
How We Compared
Our process for this Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner review starts with each brand's own listing: material, dimensions, and price, cross-checked against the three comparison products on the same criteria. None of the four listings publishes a star rating or review count, so we weighted the comparison toward verifiable facts, material composition, exact size, and current price, instead of leaning on review volume that simply is not there for any of them. We did not purchase, install, or hang any of the four products ourselves. Cotton liners occupy a specific niche among shower curtain liners because they skip vinyl and PEVA entirely, and that single material choice separates this Bean Products pick from a typical plastic liner more than any other spec in the comparison.
Overview & Specs
Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub
What we like
- 100% cotton construction with no vinyl or PEVA, a plastic-free alternative to typical shower liners
- 70 inch by 72 inch size fits most standard tubs without needing a custom cut
- A breathable fabric that avoids the sealed, humid feel of synthetic liners between uses
Flaws but not dealbreakers
- The listing does not publish a star rating or review count, unlike more established curtains reviewed elsewhere on this site
- At $60.68, it costs more than every other product in this comparison, including Bean Products' own organic cotton liners
| Material | 100% cotton |
| Size | 70"W x 72"L (Pack of 1) |
Bean Products builds this liner around a single material choice: 100% cotton, with none of the vinyl or PEVA found in most shower curtain liners. Everything else about the liner follows from that one decision. Cotton breathes in a way sealed plastic cannot, so the liner will not trap the same humid, clingy feel against skin that some PEVA liners develop between washes. It ships in one size, 70 inches wide by 72 inches long, which covers most standard tubs and shower stalls without requiring a custom cut. At $60.68, it sits at the top of the price range in this comparison, costing more than the Martha Stewart 100% Cotton Floral curtain at $59.99 and considerably more than Bean Products' own White Organic Cotton and Natural Organic Cotton liners, both $43.52. That price gap is worth weighing before buying, since the material story, cotton instead of plastic, is similar across the Bean Products options even though the sizes differ.
The tradeoff for skipping plastic is water resistance. Cotton alone does not seal out water the way vinyl or PEVA does, so most bathrooms will still want a liner or curtain behind this one to keep splashed water off the floor, which is a different setup than a typical single-liner shower. Cotton duck liners share this same limitation as a category, and shoppers choose them anyway when avoiding plastic matters more than having a fully sealed barrier. The listing does not publish a star rating or review count, which means this Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner review has less third-party feedback to draw on than a product with an established sales history. For a bathroom where a plastic-free liner is the priority and the budget allows for the higher price, this liner delivers on the one spec that matters most. Shoppers mainly chasing a lower price should look at Bean Products' own organic cotton liners first.
What We Liked
The clearest strength of the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner is what it leaves out. No vinyl, no PEVA, nothing synthetic touching the water, only cotton. That single choice appeals to shoppers who specifically want plastic out of their bathroom and are willing to trade some convenience for it. The 70 by 72 inch size also matches what Amazon lists as a standard shower curtain dimension, so most shoppers can order it without measuring a rod or tub first. Compared against Bean Products' own narrower organic cotton liners, this standard size gives it a wider fit without sacrificing the same cotton-first construction. The liner also holds its own against the Martha Stewart cotton curtain on material terms, since both skip synthetic fabric entirely, even though Martha Stewart adds a printed pattern this plain liner does not try to compete with.
What Could Be Better
Price is the most obvious drawback. At $60.68, the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner costs more than every other product in this comparison, including Bean Products' own White Organic Cotton and Natural Organic Cotton liners at $43.52 each. A shopper comparing strictly by material will notice that gap immediately, since all three Bean Products options share the same cotton-first construction. Cotton also is not a waterproof fabric on its own, so this liner needs a partner liner or curtain behind it in most bathrooms, which adds a step and a cost that a single all-in-one plastic liner would not require. On top of that, the listing does not publish a star rating or review count, so this review has no verified buyer feedback to weigh against the Martha Stewart curtain or against general expectations for cotton liners as a category. None of these issues makes the liner a poor choice, but they are the factors a shopper should weigh before paying the highest price in this group.
Who Is It For?
The Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner fits a shopper who has already decided that plastic has no place in their shower and is willing to pay a premium and add a separate waterproof layer to get that. It suits a standard-size tub or shower stall, since the 70 by 72 inch cut is a common fit rather than an oversized or narrow one. It is a reasonable match for a bathroom where natural materials matter more than convenience, and less of a fit for a rental or a busy household bathroom where a single sealed liner handling water on its own is the priority. Shoppers who want the same cotton-first approach at a lower price should compare Bean Products' own organic cotton liners below before buying. Anyone furnishing a bathroom who wants pattern as well as natural fabric might also browse our best cotton shower curtains roundup for more options beyond these four.
Alternatives to Consider
If the Bean Products liner's price or its need for a separate waterproof layer rules it out, these three alternatives cover a patterned cotton curtain and two lower-priced organic cotton liners from the same brand. All three stay under $60, and two land well under $45, so switching between them is mostly a question of pattern, size, and how much you want to spend rather than a jump to a different kind of product. None of them changes the core tradeoff of choosing cotton over plastic.
Also Great
Martha Stewart 100% Cotton Floral
At $59.99, Martha Stewart's 100% Cotton Floral curtain costs about a dollar less than the Bean Products liner and swaps the plain look for a botanical print, a straightforward option for shoppers who want pattern along with a cotton fabric.
$59.99
Check Price on Amazon
Best Value
Bean Products White Organic Cotton
Bean Products' own White Organic Cotton liner costs $43.52, roughly $17 less than the Natural Cotton Bathtub liner, while keeping the same plastic-free cotton construction in a lighter shade.
$43.52
Check Price on Amazon
Best Value
Bean Products Natural Organic Cotton
Matching its White Organic Cotton sibling at $43.52, Bean Products' Natural Organic Cotton liner offers the same savings over the Natural Cotton Bathtub liner with an undyed, natural finish instead.
$43.52
Check Price on AmazonDoes the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner need a separate liner behind it?
Cotton alone does not seal out water the way vinyl or PEVA does, so most bathrooms still pair a cotton liner like this one with a liner or curtain that can handle direct splash.
What size is the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner?
It measures 70 inches wide by 72 inches long, a size that fits most standard tubs without a custom cut.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner need a separate liner behind it?
Cotton alone does not seal out water the way vinyl or PEVA does, so most bathrooms still pair a cotton liner like this one with a liner or curtain that can handle direct splash. The Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner skips plastic entirely, which is the tradeoff for the breathable, natural feel it offers over sealed synthetic liners.
What size is the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner?
It measures 70 inches wide by 72 inches long, a size that fits most standard tubs without a custom cut. Bean Products also sells narrower, stall-width versions of its organic cotton liners for smaller shower stalls, which this comparison includes below.
Is the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner worth it compared to the Martha Stewart and other Bean Products options?
At $60.68, it costs more than Martha Stewart's 100% Cotton Floral curtain at $59.99 and considerably more than Bean Products' own White Organic Cotton and Natural Organic Cotton liners, both $43.52. Shoppers choosing between these four should expect to pay a premium for this particular standard-size cut, and the lower-priced Bean Products options are worth comparing first if budget matters more than this exact size.
Final Verdict
This Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner review comes down to price versus material consistency. Bean Products charges $60.68 for this standard-size liner, more than Martha Stewart's $59.99 cotton curtain and nearly $17 more than its own White Organic Cotton and Natural Organic Cotton liners at $43.52 each. All four options skip synthetic fabric in favor of cotton, so the choice comes down to size, pattern, and how much you want to pay for Bean Products' standard 70 by 72 inch cut specifically. For a shopper who wants that exact size and does not mind pairing it with a separate waterproof liner, the Bean Products Natural Cotton Bathtub Shower Curtain Liner is worth the higher price. Shoppers chasing a lower cost or a printed look should compare the Martha Stewart curtain or Bean Products' own organic cotton liners first. None of these four products asks for more than $61, so the downside of choosing wrong is a short wait for a return label, not a wrecked budget.

